Monday, 14 April 2025

Review: Young Men in Spats

Young Men in Spats Young Men in Spats by P.G. Wodehouse
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Worth reading just for the first Uncle Fred story, "Uncle Fred Flits By," in which that aristocratic menace causes his nephew Pongo Twistleton intense distress by improvising not one, not two, but three false identities in the course of a single afternoon, throws a middle-class family into complete and deserved uproar, and unites a worthy young couple with a generous gesture. But that's not to say that the rest of the book isn't also well up to the usual Wodehouse standard. Several of the stories are about the unfortunate love life of Freddy Widgeon, who always manages to mess things up somehow, and are told in the Drones Club by his friends, identified only as Eggs, Beans and Crumpets. Others are Mr Mulliner stories, which are always clever and funny and involve the unlikely exploits of Mulliner's large extended family.

Sadly, the electronic edition I got from my library has been scanned, run through OCR and then not properly proofread, or more likely not proofread at all; there are a lot of missing punctuation marks (full stops, quotation marks, practically all the apostrophes), "fiat" as an error for "flat," "fid" for "lid," "Camera" for "Carnera" (making a contemporary reference completely incomprehensible if I hadn't checked the Madame Eulalie annotations site), "musk" for "music" and even "sides" for "skies," not to mention surprisingly many instances of "1" that should be "I" and a couple which go the other way. A poor job by the publisher, Cornerstone Digital (= Random House, now Penguin Random House), who have had 15 years to fix this and clearly have not done so. Avoid their edition if you can; it's extremely distracting. I've read a couple of other Wodehouse books from the same imprint, and they were fine, so this one is hopefully an anomaly.

View all my reviews

Thursday, 10 April 2025

Review: The Clue

The Clue The Clue by Carolyn Wells
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Although there's a good deal of investigation by both an amateur and a professional detective, a Great Detective is called in (about three-quarters of the way through or more) and figures out something that hasn't been hinted at up to that point and requires specialist knowledge, which points to someone who has, until then, appeared an unlikely suspect and whose explanation of the crime I didn't find particularly plausible. So it's far from a "fair play" mystery, and the mystery aspect, while it is a focus, wasn't particularly satisfying to me.

Everyone is very excitable, especially the women, who are given to having hysterics and fainting when under emotional strain. I don't know if it was looser clothing or World War I making everyone more stoic, but the characters you see in detective stories of even 15 or 20 years later make all of these Gilded Age people seem absurdly melodramatic and lacking in resilience.

It had the potential to be better than it was, since it's mainly the ending that lets it down. Up to that point, it's decent for the time.

View all my reviews

Review: Four Square Jane

Four Square Jane Four Square Jane by Edgar Wallace
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Edgar Wallace was known in his day for pumping out dozens of sensational stories, a bit like some of the Kindle authors today. This one, at least, is clever, if relatively short; the introduction suggests more mystery than is actually the case around who the Jane of the title is (if he didn't want us to guess, Wallace should probably have supplied more candidates), but that doesn't take away from the brilliance and daring of her heists.

Notable for its time in that the Jewish character is not stereotyped (apart from his occupation as a financier) or subtly or unsubtly put down; he is presented as an honest, good-natured man. Instead, it's the aristocrat who is no good, and who, therefore, bears the brunt of Four Square Jane's criminal activities. She's a Robin Hood kind of figure, who often donates proceeds from her crimes to hospitals and similar institutions.

A solid bit of fun.

View all my reviews

Review: Tor the Dungeon Crawler Box Set: The Complete Death Goddess Cycle

Tor the Dungeon Crawler Box Set: The Complete Death Goddess Cycle Tor the Dungeon Crawler Box Set: The Complete Death Goddess Cycle by Jeffrey L. Kohanek
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

An entertaining sword-and-sorcery adventure series, though in many ways unoriginal and lacking a lot of polish in its details. The characters don't have a vast amount of depth or much in the way of arcs, but at least the central four are a little more than just their archetype and their plot role (though there is a secondary character whose entire personality is "sword-master"). It needs another thorough editing pass for occasional typos, homonym errors and misplaced commas, plus some dangling modifiers and a few of each of the usual issues with tense, number and punctuation. Most of them are minor issues individually, though it's long enough that collectively there are a lot of them (nearly 240 that I noticed across the three books, and I didn't start marking until partway through because I read the sample first, and you can't annotate those). The first book is the worst; the second and third have few typos, but a good many sentences that don't say what they're meant to say or mangle an idiom, and (sometimes basic) homonym errors and other vocabulary glitches. Notably, every time the author writes "crevice," which is often, he actually means "crevasse."

The author tries for "elevated" language sometimes, and mostly achieves stiff, occasionally stilted, and now and then wrong - as when he substitutes "affixed" for "fixed" in phrases like "fixed his attention," or says "he began up the stairs" instead of "he started up the stairs." This is a common error of people trying to write in a higher register than their natural one: they use what they think is a fancier synonym that sounds similar to the word they mean, but it's actually a different word with different usage and connotations. On the other hand, a lot of the time the language is less formal and filled with coarse humour, mostly about the flatulence of the dwarf.

In the first book, there's what looks like a continuity error. Early in the book, the stoneshaper dwarf, Borgli, says that stoneshapers like him can turn crystal into a substance unbreakable by anyone but another stoneshaper. But later, he says that stoneshapers' powers don't work on crystal at all.

The action is definitely up the cinematic end of things, with people swinging from ropes, catching each other as they're falling, and generally performing over-the-top feats of acrobatics and athletics. We get the accidentally-leaned-on-the-hidden-lever trope, the centuries-old-lava trope, the mysteriously-self-resetting-traps trope, the tunnel behind the waterfall, and so on. Don't wonder too hard about what the monsters live on during the long periods when there are no adventurers happening by, either. Puzzles are solved and safe paths are found by making a guess followed by an assumption that turns out to be right, though it could easily have been wrong.

(view spoiler) There's a lot of disbelief to suspend, in other words; it's a switch-your-brain-off-and-enjoy type of book.

The world is mostly generic sword-and-sorcery with not a lot of magic on stage (because the main characters are all some sort of fighter rather than magic-users), apart from things like enchanted lights and weapons and some spectacular set-pieces when they solve a puzzle or trigger a magical trap. There are a couple of times when they have a wizard with them, and those cast fairly familiar-looking spells (fireball, magic missile, lightning bolt...). When we get to a desert country, it's your basic Arabian Nights setup: camels, robes, turbans, scimitars and so on. The Big Bad is even suspiciously similar to the Raven Queen.

The one really original thing about the setting is that the countries, or "wizardoms," are all ruled by wizards, not only at the monarch level but at the level of local lords, which makes sense to me, even if it's seldom seen in fantasy. After all, wizards are powerful, and powerful people tend to end up in charge, especially in a might-makes-right world like most sword-and-sorcery stories are set in. You really need an explanation for why wizards aren't in charge (such as: they're hopelessly impractical; they're easy to kill; there aren't many of them; they're too busy studying Things Man Ought Not to Know to spend time ruling), rather than for why they are.

Anyway, there are plenty of flaws here. Still, it's an entertaining adventure that, at its best, kept me gripped and enjoying the suspense, and for that reason alone it just barely makes it onto my annual recommendation list at the lowest possible level. I should probably rate it three stars, but I've kind of painted myself into a corner with the annual lists giving four stars to anything I largely enjoyed over the past few years, so for consistency, four stars it is.

View all my reviews

Wednesday, 2 April 2025

Review: The Man in Lower Ten

The Man in Lower Ten The Man in Lower Ten by Mary Roberts Rinehart
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Never did a book so deserve my "plot-relies-on-coincidence" tag. Coincidences are everywhere, which quickly undermined my confidence that the resolution wouldn't be some kind of cheat. It isn't, at least not in that sense (more about that later).

It's as if the author only allowed herself a certain number of cast members, so she had to keep connecting them to each other and having them encounter each other in different coincidental ways. For example: the narrator, a lawyer, travels from Washington to Pittsburgh to show an industrialist some evidence in a case they're both interested in and get his deposition about it. While there, he sees a picture of the industrialist's granddaughter, who also happens to be the lawyer's partner's girlfriend, and who the lawyer also happens to meet on the train back to Washington, where an employee of the industrialist is murdered. The lawyer partners later go out to dinner, and randomly see the defendant they're proceeding against in the case I mentioned before. The narrator's life is spared twice by coincidences, too, which do at least also create complications for him.

Having said that, the prose is smooth and assured, so much so that the author can have the narrator say "I'm not an experienced storyteller, I'm telling this in the wrong order" and actually be using that to increase the tension with foreshadowing. Apparently she was known as the founder of the "had I but known" style, and there's plenty of it here.

As a pre-World War I American gentleman (he owns polo ponies and also rides to hounds), the narrator is, of course, excessively solicitous of ladies, especially but not solely ones he happens to be attracted to, and so does some stupid things in the name of not dragging his love interest and her secrets into the light. He reminded me very much of the narrator of Anna Katharine Green's The Leavenworth Case in that regard. There must be scope for present-day authors to use the current sense of what's Not Done as a similar delaying factor in the resolution of their plots, though you'd probably get caned for it on social media given who has the strongest sense of things being Not Done in our time.

I never did get straight whether the murder victim was the intended one or whether he was murdered by mistake, and it kind of doesn't matter given other (coincidental) events surrounding the murder. We find out the murderer not by the work of the amateur detective, but by someone turning up and confessing to their role in events, which to me is an unsatisfying way of resolving a murder mystery. It's as if the author is saying that the murder was only a way of driving the plot, that it's the struggles and interactions of the characters, including the wrongly accused (the narrator, though he never actually gets arrested), that are the story, and the solution of the mystery is just something that has to be delivered because it's expected; the investigation is not the story, and the detective is not the protagonist. I've read a couple of other books like this ( The Terriford Mystery and The Phone Booth Mystery: A Traditional British Mystery , and I find them disappointing. This one has other strengths, which partly make up for that disappointment, but only partly.

Well written, but structurally disappointing, because of the coincidences and because solving the mystery isn't really the main plot.

View all my reviews

Monday, 31 March 2025

Review: Recipes for an Unexpected Afterlife

Recipes for an Unexpected Afterlife Recipes for an Unexpected Afterlife by Deston J. Munden
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This book is much compared with Legends & Lattes , and for once that's accurate. Not only were they discovered by the same "tastemaker" (which is apparently a thing now), they both feature a retired Orcish warrior taking on a cozy project in food-and-beverage retail. My own feeling is that if you liked one, you'll probably like the other, though this isn't just a clone of Legends; the plot is different in detail, and so is the main character's backstory, which plays into the frontstory a lot more in this book than in the other.

The MC is not just an orc, but an undead orc, killed and then raised by a typical evil necromancer a couple of hundred years before and forced to commit atrocities as a mind-controlled thrall. He and five others broke free from the necromancer's control (exactly how is carefully not stated), destroyed him, and founded a city in which the living, the undead and those summoned from other realms could live together peacefully and prosperously. He then served the city for a long time as a member of an elite guard, but now a new ruler is taking over, and she decides it's time for him to retire from the guard, undergo a necromantic process that restores him to something much closer to life, and do what he wants instead of serving the will of others. But what does he want?

Back during the relatively brief time he was alive, he was an Orcish war chef (which I kept reading as "war chief," but it's chef), a special traditional role that's like an army cook, but respected. So he decides to open a restaurant and start cooking again. After so long, he doesn't know if he can do it, but he rapidly acquires a group of friends who encourage him: a professor who's also some sort of gang boss (but in a good way?), his restaurant employees, and a ten-year-old girl he happens to meet. This young girl turns out to have a connection to his past that requires some working through.

Although this is definitely cozy, it's not just slice-of-life without conflict. There's a rabble-rouser in the city who hates the undead (and the summoned, but mainly the undead) and believes that the living should have everything, and he and his faction cause escalating problems. And the orc and one of his oldest friends, another of the six founders of the city, come into conflict over the little girl's heritage and what it means.

From a plot point of view, all of this works excellently, and the MC has a considerable character arc which is believable and moving, involving a change of name - which is why I'm not using his name in my review. There are some indications that the author needs more experience (and more editorial input), though. To me, the employees weren't distinct enough, and I had to keep thinking hard to remember which was which, even though they were each a different kind of undead or summoned entity (it says at one point, I think, that he'd also hired living employees, but if this was true I missed which one that was, unless the vampire doesn't count as truly undead). At one point, there are two different and contradictory explanations for the origin of the orphanage (noblemen's buildings claimed by the state or a donation by the former owner) within a single paragraph. A person has grey hair on one page and brown hair on the next. I've already mentioned the careful skirting of the plot hole about how mind-controlled thralls broke out of their conditioning and overthrew the necromancer. I was sometimes taken by surprise, too, by how much or how little time had passed between two indicators of when things were happening, given the events in between.

Relevant to that last point, the author has the common fault of often not using the past perfect tense when talking about events that happened prior to the current narrative moment, which I always find disorienting and distracting. What I mean is that in a sentence that should run "she needed to trust the system she and her family had created" or "the room had never looked better" or "he had never truly let it all sink in," the "had" gets left out, resulting in a moment of temporal whiplash while I parse it.

The author also reaches beyond his vocabulary at times, and unfortunately "mediocrity" is one of the words that's apparently beyond his vocabulary (he writes "mediocracy" instead). In fact, it has a lot of small glitches, like missing words, vocabulary errors and fumbled idioms. They're not in every sentence or even on every page - there are usually two or three per chapter - and (standard disclaimer) I read a pre-release copy via Netgalley, and there may be more copy editing to come.

While all of these minor issues reduced my enjoyment (they may or may not affect yours), overall I did think this was a strong debut. It's positive and hopeful - relentlessly so at times, insisting that nobody is born evil, that we're shaped by our environment and, secondarily, our choices. The city of necromancy is, we're told over and over, one of the safest in the kingdom, though it's having an atypical time in this particular story. A dupe of the populist manipulator comes round relatively easily to a verbal appeal and admits he was fooled, which I found slightly unrealistic, but I suppose if "it's too hopeful" is one of my complaints, the author has at least understood the cozy genre. There is an unexamined tension, though, between the cozy values and the violence of a sword-and-sorcery setting, and I was never completely clear on what the fate of the antagonist actually was - which may have been another intentional skirting of an issue, or just the author not clearly conveying what was in his mind.

It lands in the Silver tier of my annual recommendation list, which is usually for solid work with no significant issues, but in this case reflects what would be a Gold-tier book (emotionally moving, strongly written) demoted by a tier for vocabulary errors, missing past perfect and not completely making sense all the time. Still a recommendation, and since most people don't notice these things and some of them may even be corrected before publication, I suspect that it has a strong future ahead of it, and possibly some awards.

View all my reviews

Wednesday, 26 March 2025

Review: That Affair Next Door

That Affair Next Door That Affair Next Door by Anna Katharine Green
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Before Miss Marple, there was Miss Butterworth.

Miss Butterworth is a very decided middle-aged spinster (middle-aged by today's standards; perhaps elderly by the standards of her time), living in the fancy New York neighbourhood of Gramercy Park. When a murder is committed in the next-door house, she - in the most dignified possible manner and with full consciousness of her social position - pokes her nose in and starts figuring things out, in tandem with the police detective, Grice, who had appeared in seven previous books by the same author, and is at this point quite old even by today's reckoning, at 77.

My big objection to the first Grice book, which is the only other one I've read by this author, was that people kept declaiming set-piece speeches about their emotions. The style seems to have settled down somewhere in the interim, and the whole book is a delight, with the notable exception of a nasty piece of anti-Chinese prejudice dropped right in the middle, apropos of nothing whatsoever. It may only be part of the characterization of Miss Butterworth's type of person and her likely prejudices, rather than the prejudice of the author, but it's a jarring note in any case. She's a slightly unreliable narrator, at least when it comes to herself, so I'm choosing to believe this was at least mostly the character's unexamined prejudice.

Miss Butterworth conveys more personality in a paragraph than, say, Freeman Wills Crofts' Inspector French does in probably his entire series (I have only read a couple of those books, but I'd risk a small bet). Take this example:

I don't like young men in general. They are either over-suave and polite, as if they condescended to remember that you are elderly and that it is their duty to make you forget it, or else they are pert and shallow and disgust you with their egotism. But this young man looked sensible and business-like, and I took to him at once, though what connection he could have with this affair I could not imagine.


Grice retains his quirk of not looking directly at people, but always picking some object in the room and apparently addressing his remarks to it, while remaining fully conscious of everything that's going on. He's smart enough to treat Miss Butterworth and her deductions and discoveries with respect, while not being so unprofessional as to open up all of his own investigation to her. She has knowledge he lacks; he's a man (who, if I remember rightly from his first appearance, is of the working class, though that's not mentioned here), and she's a woman who has spent her life in the level of society that the Van Burnams, the family who own the house where the murder was committed, also inhabit.

The mystery involves obscured identities, deceptive young gentlemen, and an odd murder which appears to have taken place in two stages. There are plenty of twisty twists and startling revelations. I've not given it my "plot-relies-on-coincidence" tag, because although the murder happens as it does because of a reasonably unlikely coincidence, and there's another coincidence later that raises the irony level, neither of them assist the plot to stay on track, which is the sense in which I mean that tag.

The only significant issue I noticed with the copy editing is that quite often something phrased as a question has no question mark.

I am demoting it a tier ranking (from Silver to Bronze) in my annual Best of the Year list, because of those couple of moments of really horrible racism, but other than that I thought it was better than most other classic mysteries I've read lately.

View all my reviews