Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Review: The Staircase

The Staircase The Staircase by A.G. Barnett
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I read a lot of classic mysteries that were actually written in the time and place (early-20th-century England) that this one is set in, and this is a decent modern version without obvious anachronisms. It does have some basic issues with not observing dialog conventions, and partly as a result of those issues, partly because of not enough tagging and partly because everyone sounds much the same, it's sometimes impossible to figure out who's speaking. Also, it's relentlessly serious, which few of the actual classic mysteries were.

The relevant conventions for dialog are these:
1. When you have some dialog and a tag (saying who was speaking), they are in the same paragraph; the tag is not a new paragraph.
2. When you have some dialog and a beat (the speaker doing something), those are also in the same paragraph, so that the reader can easily tell that the dialog and the action came from the same person.
3. When you start a new paragraph of dialog with the same speaker, you don't close the quotation marks at the end of the first paragraph, and you do open the new paragraph with a quotation mark. This author breaks this convention in two ways, either by using no quotation marks at all, or by using them in both the first and the subsequent paragraph.

The premise is that Nell, the 19-year-old daughter of an Oxford don, becomes suspicious about the death of her father's friend and colleague, who was found lying at the bottom of the staircase in his house in a position not consistent with the police theory of a fall down the stairs. She seeks out a detective who has isolated himself from the world for 10 years and convinces him to work with her on the case. She's a person who notices everything, and for some reason people confide in her readily; he has the faculty of logic and deduction developed to a high level. Together, they fight suspected crime, in a kind of Archie Goodwin/Nero Woolfe dynamic, since he doesn't leave his house.

Unfortunately, sometimes she doesn't obtain a fact until after the detective has already mentioned it as established (continuity errors, probably introduced when material was moved around), or in a couple of instances isn't shown to have obtained a mentioned fact at all. There are a couple of Convenient Eavesdrops, which is a shortcut to introduce information by having the protagonist overhear it by chance. There's a chapter that opens with a realization upon entering a room and then, without signalling, jumps back to action before Nell entered the room. Characters turn up and are named and start doing things, and we're left to infer who they are; Nell knows, but we don't, and while it's from her POV, it's not first-person narration, so we could easily be told. A "thick" letter from Nell's sister is quoted apparently in full, and is 42 words in length. These are all small things, but they add up to a general scruffiness that, along with the non-observance of important punctuation conventions and the lack of clarity in who was speaking sometimes, degraded my reading experience and took my rating down by half a star. The detective tells Nell she needs more discipline; that's also true of this author. These are relatively easy things to fix.

Underlying the story is a theme of how young women, in particular, but women and dependents in general, were managed by their elders, particularly but not exclusively men, and pressed into certain shapes regardless of whether they fit, in a sort of Procrustean bed. There's also a theme of justice versus mercy, who gets to decide whether a death was justified, which is the kind of question only the more thoughtful mysteries of the period grappled with. It deserves more polish than it's received, and I would consider giving the series a second chance in the hope that the later ones have been given more attention in the important minor details.

View all my reviews

Monday, 16 November 2026

Review: The Underachiever

The Underachiever The Underachiever by David A. Price
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I was not expecting dystopian when I picked this up from Netgalley, but that's what it is. My relationship to dystopian is like my relationship to kale: I consume some occasionally because I think it will be good for me, but I don't enjoy it.

I enjoyed this one more than most dystopians, though. Even though I'm not a big fan of the slacker/reluctant protagonist either, Wyoming Plankston, the underachiever of the title, is more likeable than most, showing a degree of empathy and a sense of justice that probably isn't common at his elite prep school (for the less intelligent sons of the rich). He's also not as stupid as his grades would suggest, just unmotivated, and he becomes motivated early in the story.

The dystopian aspect is that AIs are ubiquitous, and it's forbidden to share or talk about historical media that goes against the prevailing propaganda that AI is "kind and wise". Wyoming's love interest Kayleigh has made the mistake of doing a presentation involving the Terminator movies, which are classed as Level 3 Misinformation, and as a result has been "deauthorized"; she can't get on social media, ride in an AI-guided car beyond a certain radius of her home (and there are no non-AI-guided cars... or are there?), or use her devices online beyond that same radius.

I couldn't help comparing it with the other near-future AI-centric novel I read earlier this year, Alex Ambler's Rogue by Design: A Department of Misconfigured Intelligence Mystery , in which AI actually is kind, though not wise. Not only is the tone and the attitude to AI (and government) opposite between the two books, but the Ambler book is, to me, more technologically credible - not because the AIs are kind, but just in the general sense that it's written by someone who works in tech and knows how that whole area of human endeavour functions, whereas this book uses AI as a plot device in a way that's been done many times before. Most of the previous examples of using it this way were written before actual AI started being used (if what we have today is actual AI, which is debatable), and that means it's not really true to life. The characters don't use AI, or even technology, nearly as much as I would expect (not even as much as plenty of people do today), for example; Wyoming has to try to remember when a date with Kayleigh is scheduled for, rather than having an AI assistant put it on his calendar, or putting it there himself on his phone. The AIs don't seem to be listening to much, in fact, unless it's deliberately posted online.

Wodehouse is name-checked in the blurb, which is one reason I picked the book up. It wasn't particularly Wodehousian except that Wyoming is more-or-less a near-future American version of a member of the Drones Club - a slacker with an elite education that he hasn't absorbed very well - and there's a reference to the Black Shorts, Wodehouse's parody of the British Union of Fascists, which was as close as he ever came to politics in his books. This version is even more ridiculous, the Black Skorts, and is a pro-AI cult that refers to itself as the "dear cause" (huge red flag). Wyoming isn't very bright, but he's bright enough to see through their fanaticism, and to recognise that the poetry written by one of them, the deputy head of his school, is terrible.

Plus, the Black Skorts have treated Kayleigh badly, and he's all in on Kayleigh. Despite being better looking than he realises and from a wealthy family (although they're currently less wealthy thanks to bad investments by his uncles), he's never actually had a girlfriend before, perhaps because he's clueless and also not an insensitive jerk, so Kayleigh liking him is a big deal; and since Kayleigh wants to prevent the AI apocalypse, Wyoming is up for that too. Even if he has no idea how to go about it.

There are some pretty heavy clues laid down about how he is going to achieve his goal, and I was disappointed by the shape of the solution: (view spoiler).

There are also a few places where things don't quite fit together or aren't plausible, like the characters' phones still working fine after an EMP, seatbelts not being installed in AI-driven cars, or free speech being somehow no longer a thing in relatively near-future America. Again comparing it to Rogue By Design, this book was less realistic, more conventional and tropey, and less insightful about technology, though it was decently insightful about human beings, and I much preferred the prose style. Overall, I rate it four stars, because it's genuinely funny and there are some great lines, but the story has a few holes in it.

View all my reviews

Friday, 13 November 2026

Review: The Double-Thirteen Mystery: A Dr Hailey Detective Novel

The Double-Thirteen Mystery: A Dr Hailey Detective Novel The Double-Thirteen Mystery: A Dr Hailey Detective Novel by Anthony Wynne
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

A decent example of a classic mystery story. The murder is complicated to unravel, red herrings and clues abound and are hard to tell apart, there's a personal aspect for the detective (a young friend of his is involved with the main suspect, and possibly even with the murder), and there's action and detection and cleverness aplenty on the way to a fair-play solution. Secret codes, Russian refugees, a masked ball, it's all here.

The detective is a doctor, but in this case that's what I call a "superhero job," one that theoretically is important but in practice can be ignored entirely without making any arrangements or inconveniencing the pursuit of the plot in any way. He's also given to going off on his own into danger without telling anyone (such as his Scotland Yard bungler), and this gets him in trouble a couple of times.

Leaving that aside, it's a better-than-average mystery with lots of good pulp elements.

View all my reviews

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

Review: Super Santa

Super Santa Super Santa by Kristen Pham
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

Well-intentioned, but not a success for me.

I saw it on Netgalley and requested it because I enjoy superhero novels, and hadn't seen one in a while. They used to be very common a few years ago, but they've fallen out of fashion; now, the kind of people who were writing them mostly seem to be writing LitRPG instead. They also used to be horribly edited, and this one (even in the pre-publication version I had via Netgalley) is not, so that's good. It does have a lot of excess commas between adjectives (including after "single" and "one," which are adjectives that should never get a comma because their order is fixed), and a couple of other glitches I'll mention to the publisher in the hope that they're corrected.

It's not right in the centre of the superhero novel genre. There are elements, but it's primarily a magical Christmas story along the lines of the movie Elf, say. In fact, it's very like a typical Christmas movie, and I was utterly unsurprised when the author's acknowledgements in the back mentioned that it started life as a screenplay. That inevitably means that large swathes of it don't make a lick of sense, but as well as the bits that didn't make sense because magical Christmas story, there were some bits that didn't make sense just in general.

For example, a reasonably important plot point depends on the fact that the author apparently doesn't know that charcoal and coal are different substances, only one of which is used to grill burgers over. A scene with the reindeer outdoors in which the protagonist, Kris, starts out not knowing the reindeer's names and then, without transition, begins using them, is suddenly and also without transition apparently inside their barn. The Christmas hyena (a commendably original and fairly funny character) is not only mentally and physically capable of sending an email from an unattended computer, which I could have just barely swallowed, but knows Kris's email address without apparently ever having been told it, and what's more has an email address of his own, in the domain of the lab where he's an experimental subject, and sends from it with no apparent setup or login.

The elephant in the room, as with any Christmas story, is that secular Christmas in real life involves exactly the corporate, capitalistic, cynical exploitation that the wholesome characters are theoretically fighting against with the power of Christmas Spirit. (Said Spirit is described in exactly the words of the Force from Star Wars, which I found amusing, as I was clearly intended to.)

The characters are deeply wholesome, except of course for the cartoonishly evil villains. Kris starts out as a sad and cynical Goth girl with not much ability at anything, but is transformed by a swift training montage into a gung-ho warrior of the Christmas Spirit. Her nonbinary best friend, whose personality mainly consists of averagely gibberish technobabble, is supportive and... supportive. Nobody has much depth, not even the main character, who has the backstory for it but ducks most of the inner conflicts, and overcomes the obstacles with relative ease. The plot twists are extremely predictable, and it takes even the very intelligent character far too long to tumble to the glaringly obvious.

Kris is a Chosen One destined by blood, which is one of my all-time least favourite tropes. In fact, when I saw "zero toxic tropes" in the blurb, I thought, "that probably depends on your definition," and I was right - destiny-by-blood is a toxic trope in my book, not only because it perpetuates a myth that's been used to oppress people for centuries (by claiming that people's position in society, up or down, is justified based on inherent qualities obtained solely through their ancestry), but also because it takes away agency, and is often used as a shortcut to avoid requiring the character put in much work to become capable. I usually avoid Chosen One books, not only because I consider it an awful trope but because I consider it badly overused and without any freshness left in it, but I didn't know this was one when I picked it up.

It's not without its strengths; it's genuinely amusing at times, and it has a good heart, though the message is well worn and taken from basically every Christmas kids' movie ever. But for me, the execution was lacking.

View all my reviews

Monday, 9 November 2026

Review: A Riddle in Bronze

A Riddle in Bronze A Riddle in Bronze by Simon Haynes
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

This is a rarity: a steampunk book that isn't crammed full of vocabulary errors - though there are one or two, and it has problems with missing vocative commas (the ones that make the difference between "I don't know Jack" and "I don't know, Jack") and makes most of the common apostrophe errors. The main character is kind of an idiot, but manages to stumble his way to heroism somehow, and overall it was an enjoyable ride.

It's amusing. There's a running gag, for example, where the narrator/protagonist forms a mental image of someone before meeting them and is completely and utterly wrong. The professor is pompous, headstrong and given to calling out faults in others that he possesses himself; for some reason his housekeeper is nevertheless in love with him.

"For some reason" does a bit of heavy lifting at several points in the plot, and there were several moments that unsuspended my disbelief, like tiles on the walls of an uncompleted tunnel and a mysterious supply of faceless sacrificial victims that apparently come from nowhere. There's a strong horror element - ghosts and demons - but it's in the comic mode of Ghostbusters, and despite not liking horror I didn't find it a problem. Some of the plot twists were a bit predictable, but from a relatively short distance away.

I don't know that I'd read another in the series. It was enjoyable enough, but the romance seemed a touch forced, there were continuity issues, and it lacked that final polish that I look for. It was on the good side of OK.



View all my reviews

Thursday, 5 November 2026

Review: Magicians' Rivalry

Magicians' Rivalry Magicians' Rivalry by H.L. Burke
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

A pleasant if somewhat brief and linear YA-shading-to-NA. The two title characters are in their early 20s, but the young woman who is the sister of one and the love interest of the other is 17, and I felt it was more aimed at that age.

The somewhat estranged heir to a rural magician starts out in conflict with his father's apprentice, hence the title, but they quickly (perhaps a little too quickly) learn to work together against a common threat and become solid allies. Fast friends, if you like. There's an existential threat behind the initial more personal threats, involving the fae realm (the source of magic power), and courage and intelligence and skill from all three young people are needed to resolve it.

The editing could use a touch more work; there are some important commas missing, and some vocabulary issues ("honorary" to describe a paid post, crumbled for crumpled, posed for poised, pence used as singular, sheath for sheaf). It's not too bad.

I'd had it on my TBR for a long time, and picked it up when it went on sale. It was enjoyable enough, but there isn't quite enough here for me to want to continue in the series.

View all my reviews

Review: The Rose-Garden Husband

The Rose-Garden Husband The Rose-Garden Husband by Margaret Widdemer
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

A sweet romance from 1914. Not my usual fare, but I do like an occasional sentimental romance.

The backstory is tragic, but the present-day story is the opposite. Allan is a young man who, a few years ago, crashed his car, leading to the death of his fiancee (who was a lifelong friend) and injuring him so badly he can no longer walk or use one arm. His rather foolish mother has spent the subsequent years weeping over him, indulging him, and keeping him in a dark, quiet room. He is understandably depressed.

Now the mother is dying, and her brilliant solution is to get a wife for Allan who will look after him in her stead, because she doesn't trust his attendants to do so properly (even though his manservant is deeply loyal to him). She talks to an old school friend, who happens to know a candidate.

This candidate is our heroine, introduced at the beginning of the book as the "Liberry Teacher," which is what the children who come to the library where she works call her. Her given name is Phyllis. She's the orphaned daughter of a minister, left without much money when he died, and having to work long hours in not great conditions to scrape a living. She has no prospects of meeting anyone she'd want to marry, and she wants to escape her drudgery (even though she likes the children), so she agrees to marry Allan - a marriage of convenience, she thinks.

Of course this leads to mutual pining, misunderstandings, and an eventual happy-ever-after, because this is a romance, after all. It's well told, though, and I found it moving at times.

Certainly one could choose to disapprove of Phyllis. She's always a little conscious of being raised for better things and higher culture, and wishes that the poor immigrant children who use her library were cleaner and less... foreign. She uses a few terms about them and about the black servants she eventually has that wouldn't be used by someone like her today, though she's affectionate towards both groups. She's clearly in a wish-fulfillment fantasy along the lines of today's billionaire romances, though lower key (she just wants a rose garden and enough money to buy anything she wants, which turns out to be relatively minor extravagences). She's what the Regency would have called "missish" and this book calls "maidenly," which means she's very spooked by the idea of actually being married to a real man who she would have to... associate with. But she's unfailingly kind, naturally cheerful (even if some of her cheerfulness comes from a sense of obligation), and mostly sensible and capable, though naive and with a limited experience of life, and sometimes emotional for understandable reasons. I chose to go with how the author clearly wanted me to regard her, and enjoyed the book as a result.

I found the book through a description in the back of another book I read from the same early-20th-century publisher, and picked it up off Project Gutenberg.

View all my reviews