The Staircase by A.G. BarnettMy rating: 3 of 5 stars
I read a lot of classic mysteries that were actually written in the time and place (early-20th-century England) that this one is set in, and this is a decent modern version without obvious anachronisms. It does have some basic issues with not observing dialog conventions, and partly as a result of those issues, partly because of not enough tagging and partly because everyone sounds much the same, it's sometimes impossible to figure out who's speaking. Also, it's relentlessly serious, which few of the actual classic mysteries were.
The relevant conventions for dialog are these:
1. When you have some dialog and a tag (saying who was speaking), they are in the same paragraph; the tag is not a new paragraph.
2. When you have some dialog and a beat (the speaker doing something), those are also in the same paragraph, so that the reader can easily tell that the dialog and the action came from the same person.
3. When you start a new paragraph of dialog with the same speaker, you don't close the quotation marks at the end of the first paragraph, and you do open the new paragraph with a quotation mark. This author breaks this convention in two ways, either by using no quotation marks at all, or by using them in both the first and the subsequent paragraph.
The premise is that Nell, the 19-year-old daughter of an Oxford don, becomes suspicious about the death of her father's friend and colleague, who was found lying at the bottom of the staircase in his house in a position not consistent with the police theory of a fall down the stairs. She seeks out a detective who has isolated himself from the world for 10 years and convinces him to work with her on the case. She's a person who notices everything, and for some reason people confide in her readily; he has the faculty of logic and deduction developed to a high level. Together, they fight suspected crime, in a kind of Archie Goodwin/Nero Woolfe dynamic, since he doesn't leave his house.
Unfortunately, sometimes she doesn't obtain a fact until after the detective has already mentioned it as established (continuity errors, probably introduced when material was moved around), or in a couple of instances isn't shown to have obtained a mentioned fact at all. There are a couple of Convenient Eavesdrops, which is a shortcut to introduce information by having the protagonist overhear it by chance. There's a chapter that opens with a realization upon entering a room and then, without signalling, jumps back to action before Nell entered the room. Characters turn up and are named and start doing things, and we're left to infer who they are; Nell knows, but we don't, and while it's from her POV, it's not first-person narration, so we could easily be told. A "thick" letter from Nell's sister is quoted apparently in full, and is 42 words in length. These are all small things, but they add up to a general scruffiness that, along with the non-observance of important punctuation conventions and the lack of clarity in who was speaking sometimes, degraded my reading experience and took my rating down by half a star. The detective tells Nell she needs more discipline; that's also true of this author. These are relatively easy things to fix.
Underlying the story is a theme of how young women, in particular, but women and dependents in general, were managed by their elders, particularly but not exclusively men, and pressed into certain shapes regardless of whether they fit, in a sort of Procrustean bed. There's also a theme of justice versus mercy, who gets to decide whether a death was justified, which is the kind of question only the more thoughtful mysteries of the period grappled with. It deserves more polish than it's received, and I would consider giving the series a second chance in the hope that the later ones have been given more attention in the important minor details.
View all my reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment