Wednesday, 12 March 2025

Review: The Achievements of Luther Trant

The Achievements of Luther Trant The Achievements of Luther Trant by William MacHarg
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Something different: An early (1910) presentation of a detective using psychological science to solve cases.

Unfortunately, much of the psychological science of 1910 is bunk, and those parts of it that are valid are badly oversold. For example, the authors take it for granted that anyone who's lying will be stressed, and therefore detectable using early predecessors of the polygraph. There's a reason that polygraph evidence isn't accepted in courts: it's not that simple, not that clearcut, and not that reliable.

It reminds me, in fact, of every overhyped technology ever (such as AI today), which, when you actually start trying to apply it, comes up against the fact that the real world - and particularly the human part of it - is a lot more complicated than the technology evangelists have allowed for.

It's not all polygraph; in fact, there's quite a lot of variation, and no two stories use exactly the same method. There's some stuff about "hysteria" that, I think, takes a few laboratory experiments that were probably exaggerated in their writeup and interpretation, and turns them into "known facts" that apply generally. In one chapter, the detective solves a case based on giving a brief word-association test to a group of bank employees. In another, he measures the speed of response in a word-association test using an elaborate apparatus (all the scientific instruments are mechanical or electro-mechanical, in this time before electronics) in order to discover the guilty party. The response speeds quoted seem extremely slow for what is supposed to be a "word you first think of" test, and could easily be distinguished without using a clock accurate to a tenth of a second. We also don't ever get a discussion of how this young man, who's implied to be off a Midwestern farm, can afford to set himself up with all this presumably expensive precision equipment (once he leaves the university and goes out on his own, that is).

The whole thing takes psychological effects which, if real at all, are probably only visible in a large-scale statistical analysis, and makes them act like universal laws that apply to every subject every time, and can be easily and quickly measured outside a lab setting.

So, treat it as science fiction. But the mysteries are clever, and it's not just the same thing over and over; each story in the book presents a different type of puzzle and a different type of solution, so points to the authors for that.

There is generally a young woman in each story, but she's always engaged or married to someone already, and Trant - young, handsome and athletic as well as highly intelligent - never has a romantic interest. He is, like most early detectives, more of a crime-solving plot device than a character with his own life and interests outside detection. But if you enjoy a clever puzzle, and can suspend disbelief about the "psychological science," it's an enjoyable collection.

View all my reviews

Tuesday, 11 March 2025

Review: If I Were You

If I Were You If I Were You by P.G. Wodehouse
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The British obsession with class - and the fact that some of the brighter Brits suspected quite early on that nurture was more important than nature in creating any detectable differences between people of different classes - has produced a few comedies with a baby-swap at the centre of the plot. Gilbert and Sullivan have two (HMS Pinafore and The Gondoliers). In the US, Mark Twain did something similar, only with race, in Pudd'nhead Wilson .

Here we have a story where - according to his old nurse - the Earl of Droitwich is not the son of the previous earl, as everyone has always believed, but the son of the nurse, and the man who's grown up as the son of the nurse is not a Cockney barber but the rightful holder of the title. The Family, of course, are outraged; so is the butler, especially since the nurse in question is his sister, and he doesn't fancy calling his young nephew Sid "m'lord". The mercenary Modern Girl who has just got engaged to the man who she thought, at the time, was the earl isn't happy either.

Fortunately, the barber's manicurist, Polly Brown (a name like that in Wodehouse always signals a worthy, sensible girl), suggests that the Claimant should be shown just how much he wouldn't like earling, and the Family begin a campaign along those lines, making him ride, attend highbrow concerts and lectures, and so forth. Meanwhile, Tony, who was previously believed to be the earl, takes over the barbershop, spends time with Polly, and falls in love with her. Hijinks ensue.

The novel was based on a play, written by Wodehouse and his frequent collaborator Guy Bolton, which was never produced; they later adapted the novel into another play titled Who's Who?, which ran for 19 performances. Bolton adapted the play into a musical, Who's Who, Baby?, which was even less successful, running for 16 performances. I'm not sure why audiences didn't take to it; it's a typical Wodehouse bit of fun, with amusing dialog and situations. The novel shows its origins as a play, with limited locations and, occasionally, the feeling that the characters are saying lines to each other rather than conversing, but overall it's a solid piece in the Wodehouse manner, and I enjoyed it.

View all my reviews

Friday, 7 March 2025

Review: At the Villa Rose

At the Villa Rose At the Villa Rose by A.E.W. Mason
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

An unusual structure for a mystery story: the criminals are identified and captured just over half-way through the book, after which we get a (rather horrific) sequential account of how their crime unfolded. They're cruel and brutal, and honestly it's more than I bargained for. Then a chapter or two of how the detective figured it out.

It's a clever crime cleverly detected, but too dark for me.

View all my reviews

Thursday, 6 March 2025

Review: The Mysterious Affair at Styles

The Mysterious Affair at Styles The Mysterious Affair at Styles by Agatha Christie
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I've been reading a lot of classic mysteries lately (more than 50, not sure how that happened), and you can only do that for so long without turning to Christie. My grandmother had a collection of Christie books, which I used to read when I stayed with her, but that was many years ago, and I don't remember whether or not I read this one specifically. I've certainly seen the wonderful TV adaptation, and when I read Poirot's dialog, I hear it in my head in the voice of David Suchet. He is Poirot.

Compared with most of her contemporaries, Christie's prose feels smoother, less stiff and more modern, closer to the way people write today than to the Victorian or Edwardian style. She's not the literary stylist that Dorothy L. Sayers is, but her writing is fit for its purpose. She does occasionally commit a comma splice.

She also makes a mystery story feel like a story and not just a puzzle. The characters have more life than a lot of authors of the time manage, and in particular, her detective, Poirot, has an individuality that's missing from a lot of detectives of the era, despite its presence in the great model, Sherlock Holmes. I sometimes say that one of the things I enjoy most about a great mystery story is the parts that aren't the mystery, and Christie provides that: the interpersonal dynamics and the thoughts and feelings of the narrator all seem more developed, more in colour and less in black-and-white, than in a lot of classic mysteries.

Part of it, I suspect, is that Christie, as a woman, was permitted, even expected, to be more comfortable and familiar with emotion and relationships than the male English authors of her time, whose stories often feel like you're watching them through a window of thick glass rather than being in the same room with the characters. I've noticed a similar phenomenon with C.L. Moore in the fantasy and science fiction genre. She, like some other female authors writing at the time, introduces another layer of emotional realism and significance that's missing from most of her male contemporaries, and that we've come to expect in modern fiction.

At the same time, Christie doesn't let us down on the detective-story part. The mystery is intricately constructed and carefully unfolded, just as much as it would be in a book by one of the Freemans (Freeman Wills Crofts or R. Austin Freeman).

Hastings, the Watson character, makes a delightfully dim narrator. Take this passage, for example, where Poirot is speaking to him:


"We must be so intelligent that he does not suspect us of being intelligent at all.”
I acquiesced.
“There, mon ami, you will be of great assistance to me.”
I was pleased with the compliment. There had been times when I hardly thought that Poirot appreciated me at my true worth.
“Yes,” he continued, staring at me thoughtfully, “you will be invaluable.”


The excuse for Hastings' presence in the story is that he's convalescing from an unspecified war wound at the house of an old friend from his childhood, but the wound doesn't seem to trouble him much; he plays tennis, for example, which requires quite a sound body. He's there for a long time, too, and is eventually given a job in the War Office, suggesting that his wound is serious enough not to send him back to the Front (though clearly not so serious that he can't play tennis), or that he brings some kind of ability to the job that is not visible in his assistance of Poirot, or has some sort of influence in high places that he never mentions. It smells strongly of authorial fiat to me, used to ensure that Hastings remains present throughout the whole series of events, but nothing else in the story smells similarly, so I'll let it pass.

He's not referred to as Captain Hastings in this book, even though he's a currently serving officer. It's odd that he gets that title in future books, since he says in this one that he wasn't a professional soldier before the war, and hence technically shouldn't retain his military rank into civilian life, particularly since it's a comparatively low one; it's usually only majors and above who get to keep their rank. According to the Wodehouse annotation site madameulalie.org on their page for Lord Emsworth and Others, "In English literature, former army officers who use the rank of Captain are almost always bounders". Hastings is a strong counter-example; he’s certainly not a bounder, being, in fact, brave, loyal, and scrupulous to a fault (except that in this book he's rather too admiring of his friend's wife).

It's very solid for a first novel, and comparing it to other detective fiction of the time makes it clear to me why Christie is still the most read of all the authors working in this period (though, of course, she did continue writing for many more decades too).

View all my reviews

Wednesday, 5 March 2025

Review: Max Carrados

Max Carrados Max Carrados by Ernest Bramah
My rating: 0 of 5 stars

We aren't privy to the detective's knowledge until he explains everything at the end of each of these stories, so the enjoyment here consists of watching a clever man solve odd problems. There's an extra wrinkle in that Carrados is blind, so he relies on his other senses (and his author-given ability to reason accurately from limited information, and his extremely observant manservant) to work on the strange cases that he encounters, usually by having them brought to him by his friend the private inquiry agent. He doesn't do it professionally, having inherited a lot of money, so he can choose cases that he finds interesting - thus increasing the chances that we will also find them interesting.

The author is clever in setting up the situations and having the detective figure them out, so the stories are enjoyable, though they're not "fair play" detective stories by any measure. The author also makes sure that, usually, virtue is rewarded and vice punished, even if this sometimes requires coincidences outside the control of any of the characters, including Carrados.

The last story includes some tense moments and a bit of action, driven by Carrados being more of a protagonist than usual.

They're entertaining, but I'm not about to rush off and read others.

View all my reviews

Monday, 3 March 2025

Review: Mystery At Lynden Sands

Mystery At Lynden Sands Mystery At Lynden Sands by J.J. Connington
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

In the third Sir Clinton Driffield novel, Sir Clinton is accompanied both by his Watson from the first book (his friend Wendover, a JP who represents the sound British county chap who's a stickler for the done thing), and his inspector from the second book, who tends to play Scotland Yard bungler to Sir Clinton's Sherlock Holmes, though he's sound enough at basic police work. He can collect evidence and notice evidence, he's just not that good at stringing it together into a narrative, which is where Sir Clinton shines.

The motive for the first murder seemed pretty obvious to me, and gave a clear suspect from the start, though Sir Clinton tries to make out late in the book that it could have pointed two different ways. The main mystery, though, involved gunshots, multiple sets of footprints later washed away by the tide, several different people believing that something had taken place which had not, tyre tracks, eavesdropping, and bigamous marriages, and had me completely confused until Sir Clinton cleared it all up neatly. He's still a bit of a know-it-all; it would be nice to see him confounded, or making a mistake, from time to time just to humanize him (or having a non-professional relationship with anyone besides Wendover, who, because he's drafted as the Watson, ends up still being a professional relationship). But the crimes and solutions are clever, and if you enjoy Freeman Wills Crofts and/or R. Austin Freeman, with their puzzle-solving detectives who don't have much personality, this is another author for you.

View all my reviews

Review: Lord Emsworth and Others

Lord Emsworth and Others Lord Emsworth and Others by P.G. Wodehouse
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Short stories, in which, mostly, people win who don't always win. This is a bit of a theme for Wodehouse; he was always one for the underdog.

In the opening story, "The Crime Wave at Blandings," Lord Emsworth's despised former secretary, the Efficient Baxter, is shot with an airgun multiple times by multiple people, and another of Lord Emsworth's many nieces gets to marry the man of her choice because Lord Emsworth, emboldened by circumstances, uncharacteristically stands up to his sisters. It's prime Blandings Castle material.

We then get stories from those tireless raconteurs Mr. Mulliner and the Oldest Member (of a golf club; these are golf stories, but you don't have to be a golfer to enjoy them, since they're really about the struggles of young people in love). I'd say these stories are about average for Mulliner and Oldest Member stories: good, but not great.

Finally, we get three stories in which Ukridge uncharacteristically makes money out of his perpetual schemes, though not without the usual vicissitudes. The boxer he intermittently manages, Battling Billson, even wins a fight for once. His reluctant friend, "Corky" Corcoran, who narrates the Ukridge stories, in this case is mostly narrated to, as Ukridge recounts his triumphs and disasters. I enjoy Ukridge's inexpert con games and his eccentric costume and personality, and these three stories are well up to standard.

The cover illustration to the Everyman edition presumably is meant to be the Efficient Baxter, but with none of the features of his stated appearance (for example, his spectacles). Everyman have done an excellent job of copy editing, but I question their art direction.

The book cheered me up when I needed that, and what more can you ask from a collection of comic short stories?

View all my reviews